THAIVISION
  • REFLECTION
  • ON PLANET EARTH
    • EARTH
  • AND BEYOND
  • THAILAND
    • KING BHUMIBOL
    • NATIONAL PARKS OF THAILAND >
      • KHAO YAI NATIONAL PARK
      • PHA TAEM NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU WIANG NATIONAL PARK
      • NAM NAO NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU HIN RONG KLA NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU KRADUENG NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU RUEA NATIONAL PARK
      • MAE YOM NATIONAL PARK
      • DOI SUTHEP-PUI NATIONAL PARK
      • DOI INTHANON NATIONAL PARK
      • THONG PHA PHUM NATIONAL PARK
      • KAENG KRACHAN NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO ANG THONG NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO SURIN NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO SIMILAN NATIONAL PARK
      • HAT NOPPHARATA THARA - MU KO PHI PHI NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO LANTA NATIONAL PARK
      • TARUTAO NATIONAL PARK
  • THE LIBRARY
    • THE GREAT ILLUSION/Norman Angell
    • MORNING WORLD BOOKS >
      • CASINO ROYALE
      • 1984
      • A BRIEF HISTORY OF TIME
      • A HISTORY OF THAILAND
      • CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES
    • DEMOCRACY IN AMERICA
    • FIRST DEMOCRACY
    • JOHN MUIR
    • MODELS OF DEMOCRACY
    • MULAN
    • THE VOYAGE OF THE BEAGLE
    • ON THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES
    • PHOOLAN DEVI
    • THE REPUBLIC
    • UTOPIA
    • A Short History of the World [H.G.Wells]
    • WOMEN OF ARGENTINA
    • THE EARTH : A Very Short Introduction
    • THE ENGLISH GOVERNESS AT THE SIAMESE COURT
    • TIMAEUAS AND CRITIAS : THE ATLANTIS DIALOGUE
    • HARRY POTTER
    • DEMOCRACY / HAROLD PINTER
    • MAGNA CARTA
    • DEMOCRACY : A Very Short Introduction
    • DEMOCRACY / Anthony Arblaster]
    • DEMOCRACY / H.G. Wells
    • ON DEMOCRACY / Robert A. Dahl)
    • STRONG DEMOCRACY
    • THE CRUCIBLE
    • THE ELEMENTS OF STYLE
    • THE ELEMENTS OF JOURNALISM | JOURNALISM: A Very Short Introduction
    • LOVE
    • THE EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES
    • THE SOUND OF MUSIC
    • STRONGER TOGETHER
    • ANIMAL FARM
    • POLITICS AND THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE
    • GEORGE ORWELL
    • HENRY DAVID THOREAU >
      • WALDEN
    • MAHATMA GANDHI
    • THE INTERNATIONAL ATLAS OF LUNAR EXPLORATION
    • พระมหาชนก
    • ติโต
    • นายอินทร์ผู้ปิดทองหลังพระ | A Man Called Intrepid
    • แม่เล่าให้ฟัง
    • SUFFICIENCY ECONOMY
    • พระเจ้าอยู่หัว กับ เศรษฐกิจพอเพียง
    • KING BHUMIBOL AND MICHAEL TODD
    • ... คือคึกฤทธิ์
    • KING BHUMIBOL ADULYADEJ: A Life's Work
    • THE KING OF THAILAND IN WORLD FOCUS
    • พระราชดำรัสเรื่องร่างรัฐธรรมนูญ
  • IN MY OPINION
  • THAIVISION
  • SOMKIAT ONWIMON
    • MY STORY
    • THE DISSERTATION
    • THE WORKS >
      • MORNING WORLD
      • BROADCAST NEWS & DOCUMENTARIES
      • SPIRIT OF AMERICA
      • THE ASEAN STORY
      • NATIONAL PARKS OF THAILAND
      • HEARTLIGHT: HOPE FOR AUTISTIC CHILDREN IN THAILAND
    • KIAT&TAN >
      • TAN ONWIMON >
        • THE INTERVIEW


​THE LIBRARY

WHERE RESIDE THE WORLDS
Picture
Picture

An Unhinged Democracy in America 

Ian Buruma
Project Syndicate
http://www.project-syndicate.org

FEB 9, 2016
​
Picture
NEW YORK – Alexis de Tocqueville, a liberal French aristocrat, visited the United States in 1831 ostensibly to write a study of its “enlightened” prison system (locking people up in solitary confinement like penitent monks was the latest modern idea). Out of this trip came de Tocqueville’s masterpiece, Democracy in America, in which he expressed admiration for American civil liberties and compared the world’s first genuine liberal democracy favorably with Old World institutions.

But de Tocqueville had serious reservations, too. The biggest danger to US democracy, he believed, was the tyranny of the majority, the suffocating intellectual conformity of American life, the stifling of minority opinion and dissent. He was convinced that any exercise of unlimited power, be it by an individual despot or a political majority, is bound to end in disaster.

Democracy, in the sense of majority rule, needs restraints, just like any other system of government. That is why the British have mixed the authority of elected politicians with that of aristocratic privilege. And it is why Americans still cherish their Constitution’s separation of governmental powers.

By contrast, in the French republican system, the state represents the so-called will of the people. As a result, its authority is less constrained, which may explain the greater frequency in France of street demonstrations and even of mob violence. Indeed, these upheavals may act as informal checks on official power.

De Tocqueville identified another source of restraint in the US system: the power of religion. Human greed, as well as the temptation of going to extremes, was tempered by the moderating influence of a shared Christian faith. Liberty, in the US, was inextricably entwined with religious belief.

The spectacle of American politics today would seem to cast doubt on de Tocqueville’s observation. Or, rather, the rhetoric of many Republicans aspiring to be President sounds like a perversion of what he saw in 1831. Religion and liberty are still mentioned in one breath, but often to promote extreme views. Religious minorities are denounced. Apocalyptic fears are stoked. Intolerance is promoted. All in the name of God.

Of course, the US is not the only country where fringe demagogues are now poisoning mainstream politics. Religious language is less often heard in Western Europe, but all the more in parts of Eastern Europe, Turkey, and Israel. And the message of populism is similar everywhere in the democratic world: Liberal elites are to be blamed for all our ills and anxieties, from Europe’s refugee crisis to the inequities of the global economy, from “multiculturalism” to the rise of radical Islam.

Populism is causing considerable alarm, not least because mainstream politicians seem less and less capable of finding a convincing way to stop its rise. Those who are rightly worried about the politics of fear like to assume that populism is a threat to democracy itself. Distrust of the elites fosters distrust of the system, and the longing for great leaders who will deliver us from the selfishness of professional politicians will lead to new forms of tyranny.

That may turn out to be true. But, in fact, it is not really democracy that is presently under siege. In some ways, many societies are more democratic than they were before. If nothing else, the Donald Trump phenomenon shows that old party establishments can be skirted by popular outsiders. Social media also make it possible to bypass the traditional filters of authority, such as serious newspapers or broadcasters, and publish any point of view directly.

The power of private fortunes to sway public opinion, especially in the US, also upsets the traditional order. Anti-elitism can be fanned by vast individual wealth, because elitism is defined less by financial clout than by education.

Angry people swayed by the populist message are angrier at liberal professors, clever bankers, or skeptical journalists than they are at multi-billionaires. (It is both President Barack Obama’s elite education and the color of his skin – or, rather, the combination of the two – that has attracted so much rage.)

At the same time, people have more power to elect power-hungry crooks than they did before. Like the wild and woolly views swirling around the Internet, such figures are no longer kept at bay by traditional party elites.

What is steadily falling away is not democracy, but the restraints that de Tocqueville thought were essential to make liberal politics work. More and more, populist leaders regard their election by the majority of voters as a license to crush all political and cultural dissent.

De Tocqueville’s nightmare is not yet the reality in the US, but it is close to what we see in Russia, Turkey, Hungary, and perhaps Poland. Even Israel, which, despite its many obvious problems, has always had a robust democracy, is moving in this direction, with government ministers demanding proof of “state loyalty” from writers, artists, and journalists.

It is hard to see how traditional elites are going to regain any authority. And yet I think de Tocqueville was right. Without editors, there can be no serious journalism. Without parties led by experienced politicians, the borders between show business and politics will disappear. Without limits placed on the appetites and prejudices of the majority, intolerance will rule.
This is not a question of nostalgia or snobbery. Nor is it a plea to trust anyone with a plausible air of authority. Anger at the elites is not always unjust. Globalization, immigration, and cosmopolitanism have served the interests of a highly educated minority, but sometimes at the expense of less privileged people.

And yet, the problem identified by de Tocqueville in the 1830s is more relevant now than ever. Liberal democracy cannot be reduced to a popularity contest. Constraints on majority rule are necessary to protect the rights of minorities, be they ethnic, religious, or intellectual. When that protection disappears, we will all end up losing the freedoms that democracy was supposed to defend.

*

Read more at:
http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/american-democracy-populist-majority-tyranny-by-ian-buruma-2016-02

Ian Buruma
Ian Buruma is Professor of Democracy, Human Rights, and Journalism at Bard College. He is the author of numerous books, including Murder in Amsterdam: The Death of Theo Van Gogh and the Limits of Tolerance and Year Zero: A History of 1945.

Support Project Syndicate’s mission
Project Syndicate needs your help to provide readers everywhere equal access to the ideas and debates shaping their lives.
LEARN MORE

https://www.project-syndicate.org/donation?instanceid=679587a5-1c21-4030-a7a3-e78be0eef036

Picture
Alexis de Tocqueville กับหนังสือของเขาชื่อ Democracy in America เล่มที่ 1 พิมพ์เมื่อปี 1835 หรือ 181 ปีที่แล้ว (นับในปี 2016 ปัจจุบัน) มีความสำคัญต่อการศึกษาและพัฒนาประชาธิปไตยในสหรัฐอเมริกาเป็นอย่างมาก เป็นหนังสือที่เรียกว่า classic หรือ อมตะ นักเรียนนักศึกษาทุกคนต้องอ่าน นักการเมืองอเมริกันนิยมอ้างทุกครั้งที่มีสุนทรพจน์ หรือการวิพากษ์เรื่องประชาธิปไตย นักวิชาการมักจะประชดว่า เป็นหนังสือที่คนมักชอบอ้าง โดยไม่ได้อ่านจริงจัง เพราะที่จริงแล้วเป็นหนังสือที่ยาวมากถึงสองเล่มจบ เขียนเป็นภาษาฝรั่งเศส เพราะผู้เขียนเป็นชาวฝรั่งเศส แปลเป็นภาษาอังกฤษโดยผู้แปลหลายคนหลายสำนักพิมพ์ อย่างไรก็ตาม Volume I (1835) หรือเล่มที่หนึ่งมีความสำคัญและโด่งดังมาตั้งแต่แรกพิมพ์ในสมัยนั้น ส่วน Volume II (1840) หรือ เล่มที่สองมักได้รับความสนใจน้อยกว่า มาปีเลือกตั้งประธานาธิบดีสหรัฐ ปี 2016 นี้ ก็เริ่มมีผู้เขียนและพูดโดยอ้าง Alexis de Tocqueville แล้วตามคาด บทความภาษาอังกฤษข้างล่าง โดย Ian Buruma ผมนำมาจากโครงการ Project Syndicate ที่เป็น website ลงบทความหลายสาขาวิชา โดยนักคิดสำคัญของโลก

เรื่องราวที่เกี่ยวข้องกับหนังสือและบทแนะนำหนังสือ Democracy in America ของ Alexis de Tocqueville นั้น ผมเคยทำเป็นสารคดีโทรทัศน์ออกอากาศทางช่อง 3 นานราว 8 ปีแล้ว และได้นำลงพิมพ์เผยแพร่เป็นบทความ ที่ http://www.thaivision.com/democracy-in-america.html 


THAIVISION® 
REFLECTION ON EVENTS ON PLANET EARTH AND BEYOND 
​©2023 All Rights Reserved  Thai Vitas Co.,Ltd.  Thailand  
✉️
  • REFLECTION
  • ON PLANET EARTH
    • EARTH
  • AND BEYOND
  • THAILAND
    • KING BHUMIBOL
    • NATIONAL PARKS OF THAILAND >
      • KHAO YAI NATIONAL PARK
      • PHA TAEM NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU WIANG NATIONAL PARK
      • NAM NAO NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU HIN RONG KLA NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU KRADUENG NATIONAL PARK
      • PHU RUEA NATIONAL PARK
      • MAE YOM NATIONAL PARK
      • DOI SUTHEP-PUI NATIONAL PARK
      • DOI INTHANON NATIONAL PARK
      • THONG PHA PHUM NATIONAL PARK
      • KAENG KRACHAN NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO ANG THONG NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO SURIN NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO SIMILAN NATIONAL PARK
      • HAT NOPPHARATA THARA - MU KO PHI PHI NATIONAL PARK
      • MU KO LANTA NATIONAL PARK
      • TARUTAO NATIONAL PARK
  • THE LIBRARY
    • THE GREAT ILLUSION/Norman Angell
    • MORNING WORLD BOOKS >
      • CASINO ROYALE
      • 1984
      • A BRIEF HISTORY OF TIME
      • A HISTORY OF THAILAND
      • CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES
    • DEMOCRACY IN AMERICA
    • FIRST DEMOCRACY
    • JOHN MUIR
    • MODELS OF DEMOCRACY
    • MULAN
    • THE VOYAGE OF THE BEAGLE
    • ON THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES
    • PHOOLAN DEVI
    • THE REPUBLIC
    • UTOPIA
    • A Short History of the World [H.G.Wells]
    • WOMEN OF ARGENTINA
    • THE EARTH : A Very Short Introduction
    • THE ENGLISH GOVERNESS AT THE SIAMESE COURT
    • TIMAEUAS AND CRITIAS : THE ATLANTIS DIALOGUE
    • HARRY POTTER
    • DEMOCRACY / HAROLD PINTER
    • MAGNA CARTA
    • DEMOCRACY : A Very Short Introduction
    • DEMOCRACY / Anthony Arblaster]
    • DEMOCRACY / H.G. Wells
    • ON DEMOCRACY / Robert A. Dahl)
    • STRONG DEMOCRACY
    • THE CRUCIBLE
    • THE ELEMENTS OF STYLE
    • THE ELEMENTS OF JOURNALISM | JOURNALISM: A Very Short Introduction
    • LOVE
    • THE EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES
    • THE SOUND OF MUSIC
    • STRONGER TOGETHER
    • ANIMAL FARM
    • POLITICS AND THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE
    • GEORGE ORWELL
    • HENRY DAVID THOREAU >
      • WALDEN
    • MAHATMA GANDHI
    • THE INTERNATIONAL ATLAS OF LUNAR EXPLORATION
    • พระมหาชนก
    • ติโต
    • นายอินทร์ผู้ปิดทองหลังพระ | A Man Called Intrepid
    • แม่เล่าให้ฟัง
    • SUFFICIENCY ECONOMY
    • พระเจ้าอยู่หัว กับ เศรษฐกิจพอเพียง
    • KING BHUMIBOL AND MICHAEL TODD
    • ... คือคึกฤทธิ์
    • KING BHUMIBOL ADULYADEJ: A Life's Work
    • THE KING OF THAILAND IN WORLD FOCUS
    • พระราชดำรัสเรื่องร่างรัฐธรรมนูญ
  • IN MY OPINION
  • THAIVISION
  • SOMKIAT ONWIMON
    • MY STORY
    • THE DISSERTATION
    • THE WORKS >
      • MORNING WORLD
      • BROADCAST NEWS & DOCUMENTARIES
      • SPIRIT OF AMERICA
      • THE ASEAN STORY
      • NATIONAL PARKS OF THAILAND
      • HEARTLIGHT: HOPE FOR AUTISTIC CHILDREN IN THAILAND
    • KIAT&TAN >
      • TAN ONWIMON >
        • THE INTERVIEW